Mornings in New Buffalo have a special kind of charm. The harbor is just waking up, the beaches are quiet, and the scent of coffee drifts from the town’s cozy cafés. Whether you’re here for a quick weekend getaway or staying longer at Copper Top Ridge, breakfast in New Buffalo is where the day begins.

The big question: where should you eat breakfast in New Buffalo when morning hunger strikes? From indulgent brunches with friends to a quick coffee before hitting the lake, here’s your ultimate guide.

🍳 Best Brunch in New Buffalo

Brewster’s Italian Café

brewstersnewbuffalo.com
Tucked into downtown, Brewster’s is one of the most popular destinations for brunch in New Buffalo. Known for its authentic wood-fired pizzas, frittatas, and hearty pasta dishes, this Italian-inspired café shines in the morning.

• Why Go: The shady outdoor patio feels like a Tuscan escape.

• When to Go: Breakfast runs until 11:30 AM.

• Insider Tip: Reservations are highly recommended, especially on weekends and summer mornings.

• Pair It With: A visit to New Buffalo Public Beach, just a short walk away.

Beer Church Brewing Co.

beerchurchbrewing.com
Few places capture the spirit of breakfast in New Buffalo like Beer Church. A Civil War–era church turned brewery, it’s both historic and playful.

• Highlights: Communion Toast with avocado and eggs, breakfast pizzas, and biscuits & gravy.

• Drinks: Craft beer flights, bloodies, and mimosas.

• Atmosphere: Heated beer garden + Michigan’s largest outdoor bar.

Beer Church is also a great starting point for exploring more of Harbor Country. Pair brunch with our guide: Savor Southwest Michigan: The Best Wineries and Tasting Rooms Near New Buffalo.

Bentwood Tavern

bentwoodtavern.com
For an upscale take on brunch in New Buffalo, Bentwood Tavern delivers. With waterfront seating on the marina, it blends cozy hearth-side dining with seasonal, locally inspired fare.

• Why Go: Brunch runs daily from 9 AM to 3 PM.

• Best For: Couples and groups seeking a refined yet relaxed brunch.

• Pair It With: A walk on the Galien River boardwalk.

☕ Quick Coffee & Breakfast in New Buffalo

Not every morning calls for a full sit-down meal. For travelers on the go, these spots are perfect for a quick breakfast in New Buffalo:

• David’s Delicatessen & Coffee – Famous for bagels, fresh coffee, and their breakfast Reuben.

• Issa Vibe Café – A trendy spot for smoothies, vegan pastries, and lattes.

• Whistle Stop Grocery – Grab scones, sandwiches, and picnic-ready snacks.

🍳 Breakfast at Copper Top Ridge

Sometimes the best breakfast in New Buffalo is the one you make yourself. At Copper Top Ridge, our fully equipped kitchen, oversized island, and dedicated coffee station make mornings a delight.

Guests often shop local produce at the New Buffalo Farmers Market and cook up their own feast.

• Brew a latte while watching deer in the backyard.

• Whip up eggs and bacon before a beach day.

• Share pancakes with the family at the island.

Coffee lovers will find K-cups for convenience, plus a grinder and multiple brewing methods: drip machine, percolator, and French press. Bring your favorite beans or buy fresh from the farmers market for a personalized cup.

🥞 Bonus: Bring Brunch Home

Want to bring New Buffalo brunch vibes into your own kitchen? Check out the Beautiful Brunches. It’s packed with over 100 sweet and savory recipes for bunch — perfect for recreating favorites from Brewster’s or Beer Church.

Final Thoughts

Breakfast in New Buffalo is as varied as the town itself. Whether you’re sipping coffee at David’s, enjoying brunch at Brewster’s, Beer Church, or Bentwood, or cooking your own at Copper Top Ridge, mornings here are meant to be savored.

From hearty brunches to quick bites, New Buffalo restaurants and cafés serve up something for everyone — one bite, sip, and sunrise at a time.