Searching for the best pizza in Southwest Michigan? Whether you’re road-tripping along the coast or cozying up at Copper Top Ridge, this guide has you covered. From wood-fired pizza with a lakeside view to bubbling deep dish in charming small towns, discover the region’s top pizzerias and where to eat pizza in Harbor Country.

🍺 Beer Church Brewing Co. – New Buffalo, MI

Style: Wood-fired artisanal
Crust: Thin, blistered, with chewy edges

Beer Church Brewing is not only one of the most iconic spots for pizza in New Buffalo, it’s also one of the most unique dining experiences in Harbor Country. Housed in a restored Civil War-era church, their wood-fired oven turns out bubbling pies that are as memorable as the setting.

What to Try: Sweet Lou – house sausage, hot honey, and mozzarella.

🎓 Extra Fun: Sign up for their Pizza School, where you’ll learn to craft your own wood-fired pie. It’s a perfect date night, group activity, or foodie adventure, and ties right into our roundup of cooking classes in Southwest Michigan.

🔥 The Rolling Stone Wood Fired Pizza – Bridgman, MI

Style: Neapolitan-inspired wood-fired
Crust: Thin, blistered, airy edges

One of the top destinations for wood-fired pizza in Michigan, Rolling Stone’s high-heat oven turns out pies in just 90 seconds. With a minimalist menu and flavor-forward ingredients, it’s a must-stop on your Southwest Michigan food tour.

What to Try: Sweet Heat – fresh mozzarella, hot honey, Calabrian chili.

🧭 Pair With: A dune hike at Warren Dunes State Park and check out our Lake Michigan Beaches Guide.

🧀 Silver Beach Pizza – St. Joseph, MI

Style: Midwest tavern-style
Crust: Medium-thick, chewy, pan-baked

This lively lakefront pizzeria is practically a pilgrimage for many weekenders from Chicago. Known for its cheesy, over-the-top pies and iconic location next to the Amtrak line, Silver Beach Pizza is one of the most beloved pizza places in Southwest Michigan.

What to Try: The Carnivore – sausage, pepperoni, ham, bacon.

🌅 While You’re There: Take a sunset stroll on the Silver Beach Pier.

🍅 Capozio’s – Harbert, MI

Style: Chicago-style deep dish
Crust: Buttery, dense, baked in a pan

A longtime local favorite for deep dish pizza in Michigan, Capozio’s delivers fork-and-knife comfort food with classic toppings and rich red sauce. Their retro Italian vibe makes every dinner feel like Sunday at Nonna’s.

What to Try: Sausage & Green Pepper Deep Dish

🧭 Nearby: Grab a bottle to go from Domaine Berrien Cellars and have your own Italian night in.

🥓 Stop 50 Wood Fired Pizzeria – Michiana Shores, IN

Style: Artisanal Neapolitan-style
Crust: Thin, lightly charred, chewy

Just south of the border but part of the Southwest Michigan pizza orbit, Stop 50 is a masterclass in dough fermentation and wood-fired balance. Their seasonal pies are as elegant as they are flavorful.

What to Try: Fig + Prosciutto – gorgonzola, arugula, balsamic drizzle.

🔥 Perfect Pairing: Add it to your evening after a kayaking trip on the Galien River.

🍕 Villa Nova Pizzeria – New Buffalo, MI

Style: Thin crust tavern-style
Crust: Ultra-thin, crispy, square-cut

If you’re wondering where to get pizza in New Buffalo, Villa Nova is the answer. Their crisp crusts and old-school bar setting are Harbor Country through and through. A great spot for a late-night slice and a classic cocktail.

What to Try: Sausage & Mushroom

🍸 Vibe: Start with pizza, stay for drinks, then catch a show at The Acorn Theater nearby.

🌿 Brunetta’s – Sawyer, MI

Style: Farm-to-table gourmet
Crust: Rustic, hand-stretched, wood-fired

Brunetta’s elevates pizza in Southwest Michigan with seasonal toppings, organic ingredients, and a focus on local farms. Their warm interior and artfully plated pies make this a date-night favorite.

What to Try: Squash Blossom Pizza with lemon ricotta and basil

🌾 Extra Flavor: Stop into Greenbush Brewing Co. next door and check out our Winery & Brewery Tour.

🏆 Discovering the Best Pizza in Southwest Michigan

🏆 Why These Are the Best Pizza Places in Southwest Michigan

🍽️ Bonus Pizza Stops Worth the Detour

• Mario’s Pizza – Benton Harbor, MI
  New York-style giant slices. No frills, just flavor.
• Tim’s Too – St. Joseph, MI
  Mongolian grill with pizza ingredients? Wild—but fun.
• Casey’s – New Buffalo, MI
  Pub-style thin crust + live music = pizza party.

🔚 Final Slice

When it comes to the best pizza in Southwest Michigan, you’ve got options as wide as a family-sized pie. Whether you crave wood-fired bubbles, crispy squares, or decadent deep dish, these spots deliver—each offering a slice of what makes Harbor Country so deliciously unique.

Staying at Copper Top Ridge? Keep the cravings going with our guides to kayaking adventures, Lake Michigan beaches, and the best wineries nearby.

🍕 Got a favorite spot we missed? Tag us with #CopperTopCravings and share your perfect slice.