Craving a creative and cozy dining experience on your things to do in Southwest Michigan itinerary? Brewster’s New Buffalo, a locally owned Italian-inspired eatery, delivers imaginative fare from breakfast through dinner. Housed in a charming downtown storefront, they serve wood-fired pizzas, homemade pasta, and seasonal small plates—all crafted with fresh, locally sourced ingredients.

Just a short walk from the New Buffalo Public Beach, Brewster’s is ideally placed for a leisurely meal after a morning of sun and sand. The restaurant’s sommelier-curated wine list and craft cocktail menu make it a perfect stop for couples enjoying a romantic cottage weekend or families exploring breakfast spots in New Buffalo. Its laid-back sophistication provides a culinary contrast to casual lake days, making it one of the town’s most versatile dining options.

After your meal, stroll through downtown New Buffalo’s shops and attractions to round out the experience. Located minutes from Copper Top Ridge, Brewster’s New Buffalo is consistently ranked among the top restaurants in Southwest Michigan—voted “the best restaurant in town” by travelers on TripAdvisor and featured on OpenTable.